Just thought I’d update, sorry for taking so long. Oddly enough I went out the next morning to start checking everything, tried to start it, and after just a little hesitation it started right up! I have been driving it for 2 days now, and have not been able to replicate the symptoms. I do have a CEL on so I took it to AutoZone to have it tested and there are some issues with the EGR. I’ll swap that out when I get some extra money and see if it helps anything.
Thanks again guys for all of your ideas!