Menu

Synthetic vs Regular Oil

Home Forums Stay Dirty Lounge The EricTheCarGuy Video Forum Synthetic vs Regular Oil

  • This topic has 144 replies, 63 voices, and was last updated 6 years ago by MikeMike.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #493950
    EricTheCarGuy 1EricTheCarGuy
    Keymaster

      I’m sure this one will have a few opinions, I look forward to yours.

    Viewing 15 replies - 76 through 90 (of 144 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #499353
      Lord IhcalamLord Ihcalam
      Participant

        ive also been told that if your car sits for long periods of time (like a classic that doesnt get driven but on really nice weekends during the summer) that synthetics are more forgiving to storage too.

        #499407
        Matt BlackledgeMatt Blackledge
        Participant

          There are lots of differing opinions here. For what mine is worth, I would always choose the best oil I can get on offer, a change it every 5,000 miles. It cost me about £25 to put castrol magnatec and a good quality filter on mine and my girlfriends cars. So whats that $78 a year per car. Some people might think this a lot, but lets face it there isn’t one of us that hasn’t bought lunch out, or bought that shirt we wanted but didn’t really need.

          You don’t expect your house to burn down, but would you run the risk of failing to insure it in the hope it didn’t? I know from experience, your glad you insured your house when it does! That’s not to say the other opinions aren’t valid, because everyone’s opinion is exactly that, an opinion. But it makes me feel safer to do the best I can for my car without costing me a fortune. Shopping around or waiting for the sale can mean the difference between a top notch synthetic and a own brand regular oil.

          #499413
          jeffreyjeffrey
          Participant

            Now what are the brands that are called synthetic but are actually a blend because of a loophole? Is Mobile 1 really full synthetic?

            #499427
            Lord IhcalamLord Ihcalam
            Participant

              i think because of a court case, anything labeled full synthetic is fully sytnthetic oil. major brands such as catrol and valvoline and quaker state sell semi synthetic or synthetic blended oil. penzoil does too, but i was taught by my grandfather (a master mechanic for over 50 years) to never use penzoil, not even in a lawnmower. you can usually tell the difference by bottle color, silver is often the blend gold the full, or the prices, semi will be somewhere halfway between standard motor oil and full synthetics.

              i’d like info and opinions on those new bio oils. biodegradable and all that. does it mean i can just dump it in the ditch across from my house? (thats a joke btw) also what about green recycled oil?

              #499470
              davedave
              Participant

                synthetic + oil = soil

                you should put soil in your engine.

                #499541
                ronaldronald
                Participant

                  [quote=”jeffrey” post=48659]Now what are the brands that are called synthetic but are actually a blend because of a loophole? Is Mobile 1 really full synthetic?[/quote]

                  It prob depends on the actual oil there may be some mobile 1s which are pure synthetic but most are PAO blended oils

                  examples of pure synthetics = motul 300v (ester), redline (ester), royal purple (PAO), amsoil (PAO), penrite 10-10ths (aussie – ester+PAO)

                  #499556
                  jeffreyjeffrey
                  Participant

                    So Mobile 1 isn’t a pure synthetic? (hhmmm..I hate it when a company bs’s me.) Is there a way to tell on the bottle? Group III’s or some such? …and what is the real deal?

                    #499752
                    Dan TattershallDan Tattershall
                    Participant

                      These articles were written by a chap in the know from silkolene/fuchs:
                      http://www.opieoils.co.uk/t2-technical-info.aspx

                      #499932
                      ronaldronald
                      Participant

                        [quote=”jeffrey” post=48737]So Mobile 1 isn’t a pure synthetic? (hhmmm..I hate it when a company bs’s me.) Is there a way to tell on the bottle? Group III’s or some such? …and what is the real deal?[/quote]

                        mobile 1 is NOT 100% man-made. it is a PAO blend (group 4). mobile 1 is still good. unless you track your car regularly there is no point in getting a pure group 4/5 oil

                        #500256
                        ChevypowerChevypower
                        Participant

                          What about Dexos?

                          #500312
                          EricTheCarGuy 1EricTheCarGuy
                          Keymaster

                            I have no experience with that product so I don’t have any opinions sorry.

                            #501401
                            john barryjohn barry
                            Participant

                              With regards to oil grades look for the German manufacturers approvals, Mercedes,VW, BMW & Porshe on the back of the oil container.
                              As a rule of thumb these guys are really strict about oil quality so if it has their endorsement you can’t go wrong.
                              (you’ll be surprised how many top end oil Brands don’t)

                              #501405
                              Dan TattershallDan Tattershall
                              Participant

                                When it comes to oil i have always tried to use the best i can afford & have always looked into the technical specs of the oil as some “premium/well known” brands are no where near as good as the smaller less known producers… I currently use Millers CFS 10w40 Fully Synth it costs about £55 for 5L… But i do go on track days (not certain if you can get that over there) but Motul 300V is a good oil from what i’ve read. It really does depend on application & personal budget. Interms of Mobil 1 they are the same as most oil companies & produce some semi & some fully synth.

                                #501409
                                Dan TattershallDan Tattershall
                                Participant

                                  Most german manufacturers only specify semi synth too as thats all most applications call for

                                  #501423
                                  NickNick
                                  Participant

                                    [quote=”Chevypower” post=49097]What about Dexos?[/quote]

                                    Dexos is an oil standard. vital to some GM diesels.

                                    http://www.gmdexos.com/licensedbrands/dexos2licensedbrands.html

                                  Viewing 15 replies - 76 through 90 (of 144 total)
                                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                  Loading…