Menu

Rough Idle/Random Misfire

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #873699
    Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
    Participant

      Hi, I’m really hoping someone here can help me figure this out. My 2005 Land Rover LR3 with 126,000 miles started acting up a couple weeks ago. It began with just a poor idle. I’d describe it as an occasional rhythmic “BLURP”…??? Kind of like a mini backfire that you can’t hear but you can feel. That progressed after a couple of days to a full blown rough idle with loss of power and rough acceleration. Thats when I started getting the DTC’s. Cylinder 8 at first. Changed the coil from 8 to 6 and drove it a bit. That’s when I got codes for 3, 4, and “RANDOM MISFIRE” followed shortly there after by the dreaded “REDUCED ENGINE PERFORMANCE” message on my dash. BTW, cylinder 8 never threw a code again. So I changed the MAF, reset the driver adaptaion log and reflashed the TCM. That seemed to fix the issue until I let it sit for a few hours. When I started her up… Same thing. Rough idle, random misfire and REDUCED ENGINE PERFORMANCE. I let it be for a bit because I’m trying to avoid throwing parts a the car in the hopes of fixing it. So over the past week I noticed that if I drive the car long enough the symptoms go away completly and it runs perfect. So I started collecting live data via the torque app and I came to find that when the engine approaches 170 degrees the engine starts to smooth out. by full operating temp of 190 or so it runs and performs perfectly. this is leading me to suspect a sensor that gauges temperature. I’d really appreciate it if anyone has any input on the subject because from what I’ve read anything gauging temp usually results in bad performance when hot rather than cold.

    Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 45 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #873700
      RichRich
      Participant

        Given you’re using Torque, what do your fuel trims look like at idle and ~2500 RPM? Be sure the car has warmed up to closed loop before taking the measurements.

        #873701
        Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
        Participant

          Thanks for the response. I just downloaded Torque a couple days ago and I’m still learning how to use it. I’ll take a look and see if I can get that going then I’ll post results.

          #873724
          Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
          Participant

            Hi again, first let me say thanks for taking the time to help. I really appreciate it. I configured the Torque app as best I could based off information online and YouTube. I uploaded a video of Fuel Trim and O2 sensors to YouTube here; https://youtu.be/MLqhFgOSOnw Once again thanks!

            #873750
            Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
            Participant

              OK, I learned a little more on Fuel Trim and realized I’m monitoring the wrong one. Here is a video of a short road trip. Any help would be appreciated. https://youtu.be/ePG1TPnwIw8

              #873751
              Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
              Participant

                That was done on a closed loop. The widget for fuel system status isn’t available on the video recorder plugin.

                #873757
                cj1cj1
                Participant

                  Can you post all error codes and freeze frame data for the error codes?

                  #873758
                  Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
                  Participant

                    Thanks for the reply! I’ll get the trouble codes but I’m not certain as to how I can “freeze frame” the data

                    #873759
                    cj1cj1
                    Participant

                      The Torque app must have it somewhere in the menu.
                      Sorry not familiar with the product.

                      #873760
                      Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
                      Participant

                        I’ll do some research to see if I can get that going. I don’t know if you’re if you’re familiar with JLR SDD but I have that too. Unfortunately all I’ve learned to do on that is pull codes, choose symptoms and reset my TCM

                        #873761
                        cj1cj1
                        Participant

                          Try to determine:
                          Misfires on one bank only, cylinders 2/4/6/8, or mixture of banks?
                          Misfires at cold startup only?

                          Fuel trim numbers posted at warm startup into closed loop look pretty normal at idle and higher RPM.

                          #873762
                          JamesJames
                          Participant

                            Just to not ignore obvious. Have you checked your coolant level and made sure there was no air in the system. I know Eric has mentioned that , that will mess with the Honda’s in the way you describe.

                            #873763
                            Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
                            Participant

                              Bank 1 is; 1,2,3,4 Bank 2 is; 5,6,7,8. My first DTC was for misfire on 8. I swapped #8 coil with #6. The subsequent codes have been for #3 (only one occurrence a week ago) and random misfire. Random misfire happens not at startup but rather upon acceleration. This doesn’t occur once my engine temp is above 170 or so

                              #873764
                              Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
                              Participant

                                I just changed out every hose/hose assembly on the car as well as the thermostat over the summer. There was only one I couldn’t get to because it’s under and feeds the intake manifold. The radiator was flushed and the system was filled and burped. But now that you mention it, I am getting a whiff of leaking coolant that I suspect is coming from the intake manifold. Also to note, the reason I didn’t change that one is because there is a bolt in the back of it that’s under the cowling and I was afraid I wouldn’t be able to get it back in and tightened. But I didn’t find out about that bolt until I removed the others and tried to lift the manifold. Could it be possible that my gaskets are no longer sealing properly?

                                #873765
                                cj1cj1
                                Participant

                                  “Could it be possible that my gaskets are no longer sealing properly?”
                                  Yes, possible not sealing at startup but seals as engine heats up.

                                  Do a water spray leak detection tests around/over the intake gasket.

                                  #873766
                                  Christopher MoffittChristopher Moffitt
                                  Participant

                                    Thanks for the advice! Now here’s where I ask a stupid question… Is this test as simple as it’s title? Spray some water and wait to see if it gets sucked in?

                                  Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 45 total)
                                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                  Loading…
                                  toto togel situs toto situs toto