Quoted From ChrisR1987:
Both are good deals. Ive been toying with the thought of finding a cummins at a junkyard and pulling it. Im just not sure with the lack of documentation and the orginizatiobn of the parts if everything is there. Im actually trying to figure out if the 6.9 has head studs as I cant find those in the bucket of parts that came off the heads.
Im not sure how the cummins dodges vary from one gen to the next. I know rumor has it the first generation the bodies fall apart around the motor, the 2nd gens had steering, transmission, and suspension issues. Not sure after that
if i remember right they was bolts factory but even if you do find them do not use them. you should get new unless you have high quality aftermarket studs. other wise you have a high chance of blowing head gaskets.
far as the rumors well they are rumors. you could say i have a chicken living on my head and some one is bound to believe it. haha 1st gen haveing body issues is a new one to me? when you have a engine that was built and does last so long like the cummins it is hard to build a truck to live as long no matter the brand. many times the cummins is swaped into a ford or chevy and out lasts that pickup to. far as steering on 2nd gens well what pickup don’t have slop in the steering at 200,000 + miles? i havent seen one yet that don’t unless its all new. the ball joint one that so many like to point out well that one is easy to debunk. it is the same ball joint as ford threw the 90s and early 2000s. infact the hole axle is the same made by the same company. the only difference was ford used a smaller dana 50 on some of theres. the dana 60s are the same. how is it any weaker then ford? now trannys again it really is not that bad when comparing. in my life i have seen many dodge chevy and ford auto trannys die at a very low milage and do not see one sticking out. only in rumors or internet arguements where everyone has a friend with a dodge that had a tranny go bad haha notice non of them have owned and drove one there self.
what i really want you to take from this is many times rumors have no real backing. it is just a opinion or made up from some one that is brand stuck because of there dad or friends or where ever it came from.
personally the only thing i see good or bad that stands out between the 3 is the cummins just lasts forever. other then that it is abuse, maintenance, age, and milage. personally i like manuals anyways so i don’t normally have any tranny issue with any brand. hope that helps my friend.